Acquired by NBC after all thirteen episodes of the show were produced, Persons Unknown is an international coproduction from Fox and Usual Suspects writer Christopher McQuarrie. Like Lost and various other shows in the last few years, Persons Unknown brings together a group of disparate individuals with seemingly no connection. There’s the single mother going through a divorce, a US marine, a car salesman… you get the picture. Each one is kidnapped and wakes up in a hotel room in an abandoned town surrounded by nothing but mountains. The characters are monitored by surveillance cameras. By who exactly, we don’t know. And of course none of the kidnapped characters trust each other, and with good reason. Meanwhile, a journalist in San Francisco begins investigating the disappearances.

Persons Unknown is definitely chock full of atmosphere. Muted colors and an array of assholey characters (the journalist’s co-worker) are enough to create Saw comparisons. Due to this being an NBC show there is much less gore. The psychological element, however, is just as strong even if the characters do seem ever so slightly dense at times.

What does not work however is the structure. Alternating between the main cast and the journalist diminishes tension. The cliffhanger for the final episode is the reveal of a fortune cookie message that the protagonist received five minutes prior. The camera randomly focuses on this during a tense scene in which the cast are interrogating the hotel’s bellman. The random and sudden nature of this reveal means it did not feel like an inevitable outcome that the rest of the episode had been building to as much as a way to quickly wrap the pilot up and leave the viewers anticipating next week. And it worked. However, these kinds of out-of-nowhere cliffhangers can be the difference between good storytelling and manipulative storytelling and if this becomes a pattern in Persons Unknown it could grow annoying.

All things considered, the pilot to Persons Unknown was definitely a promising start to a series that in theory has everything working against it (NBC, summer scheduling, NBC, unknown cast, NBC, serialization, …NBC) and if it lives up to the mystery presented so far could be well worth the watch this summer.

Klara Prast – Runaways

After Brian K. Vaughan passed the torch to Joss, most of us didn’t know what to expect. However, in the second stint of the Runaways comic, Joss created twelve year old Klara, who lived in the olden days of America in 1907, where she was the forced to be the wife of a much older man. For stunning parallels to events still going on around the world in current days, Klara has seriously earned her spot on this list. There’s also Molly re: wifely duties – “They make you do chores?!?”

Robot Phil – Sugarshock

But wait, there’s more! Joss also handled the world of original comics in this mini-series from Dark Horse. Follow the adventures of a punk rock band that also battles aliens. With cheese. For showing us that robots can make cracks, as well as play bass, Robot Phil gets the nine spot.

Bad Horse – Dr. Horrible

How can someone make the list with just a letter? Only if Joss is at the helm. Bad Horse is actually a horse who has a chorus do all the talking/singing. Plus, the chorus rocks.

Skip – Angel

One of the most intimidating characters in the Angel-verse was apparently one of the most pleasant. With lines like, “you really think a guy built like this would be so easy to drop?” apparently one of Skip’s most difficult problems was his commute. However, he stood out for not being what he seemed, being what he seemed, then not again.

Victor’s Topher – Dollhouse

Yes, Victor and Topher both had their actor’s names on the opening credits. But for seamlessly merging with another’s character in the episode “The Left Hand” - and making the Dollhouse technology suspiciously possible - Enver Gjoka deserves a nod. Plus, Topher having a conversation with “himself” was something only Joss could do.

Badger – Firefly

Although Mark Sheppard would go on to do bigger and Battlestar-y-er things, I best remember him as the guy with the bowler hat whose original name was probably Beaver. It is also rumored that Joss himself was set to play the role, which conflicts the fan in me who would have liked to see both. If in doubt of Badger’s worthiness, please recall: “You couldn’t buy an invite with a diamond the size of a testicle. I got my hands on a couple.”

Drusilla – Buffy

While arguments may be made if the vampire Nancy (as in Sid &) of the second season is a secondary or tertiary character, Drusilla is completely bonkers, which makes her a feature of any best character list. Also doesn’t hurt that Juliet is currently tearing up the web and sharing what inspires her favorite artists with the world.

Polo – Angel

For starring in one of the best episodes of anything, ever, Polo is best known for his leadership of the “Smile Time” gang. In an episode of Angel that pretty much told the shark to “jump this,” Angel and gang encounter a band of demon puppets set on draining the life of children. The rest is better off watched than read.

Whiskey – Dollhouse

Better known as Dr. Saunders, Whiskey truly only appears in flashbacks. What makes her stand out is that even after being the puppet of several different masters she still knew who she was. Bonus points for the revelation no one saw coming and another fine performance from Amy.

Jonathan - Buffy

Can a tertiary character steal the show? When Buffy is the show and Joss Whedon/Jane Espenson are the writers he can. Jonathan fulfilled a fantasy - as an entire episode - that every Whedon fan has: to be part of the Scooby Gang. “Superstar” was also an episode that any series in its fourth year could have just phoned in. Going much the opposite route, Jonathan, more or less the show’s resident geek, casts a spell causing the world to see him in a whole new light. But for the show’s name and central character, Jonathan manages to grab a piece of the spotlight for himself and all the following top ten Whedon tertiary characters.

Special Mention: Lockheed – Astonishing X-Men

Joss neither created nor conceived of the tiny alien dragon. However, his perfectly timed reappearance in Astonishing X-Men is worth mentioning and reading.

All the good things you’ve heard about this film are true. It’s a good superhero film.

So why does it feel like this review is going to be negative?

What Iron Man 2 represents is your standard, lazy superhero film – carefully monitored by the studios so as to be a safe bet come opening weekend.

Fortunately it’s a sequel, so we’re spared a first act dedicated to the origin story. Unfortunately, however, it’s a sequel. So in true three act style, we’re treated to a retread of the Hero’s Journey. If you’ve seen Spider-Man 2, Spider-Man 3 or The Incredible Hulk you practically know how the story goes.

He’s already a hero. So you’re going to see some shots re-establishing him in that hero role. This could take the form of a breath-taking set piece. But the film needs a reason to exist. It has to be different from the first one. The hero has to be tested. Cue: Tony Stark slowly dying. Set up a villain and time their first confrontation at the thirty minute marker. Bingo, you’ve got yourself the first act of a superhero film.

During the second act everything escalates. And then in the third act there’ll be a big set piece, the hero’s arc will be resolved, as will the various other plot threads.

This is fine. It’s textbook. Tells a story.

The problem is it feels like a story I’ve seen a trillion times over since Bryan Singer first secreted X-Men ten years ago.

Superhero films have gone from being a nothing entity in the nineties to becoming a genre all their own. I don’t know which is worse.

Films based on superhero comics shouldn’t have to be a genre. They should be a sub-genre.

Kick-Ass was a step in the right direction. A teen film that just so happened to have a superhero in it. And it was post-modern. And it was non-linear.

The Dark Knight… It felt like a crime film that just so happened to have a superhero film in it.

Ang Lee’s Hulk… Like it or loathe it, it was far less by the numbers than it’s 2008 counterpart.

As a genre, superhero films tend to suck. As a sub-genre, they suck a little less.

They need to shake it up a bit, to coin a phrase from Sue Sylvester.

Iron Man makes a great action movie. And they hinted on a promising character arc: the dying narcissistic hero who can’t take anything seriously.

It’s promising stuff. But in the comics he’s an alcoholic for God’s sake. I want darkness with my explosive set pieces. Never have I been more entertained in my life than when Jack Bauer was crawling around on his office floor, sweating and detoxing from drugs at the beginning of Day 3. That’s an action show. With a drug addicted hero. It was a wonderful combination. Make Iron Man an alcy. I don’t want a gritty knock off of a Dolph Lundgren movie. Just give me a little depth. Tony Stark’s imminent death led to little more than him urinating himself and squabbling with War Machine. I want more, damnit.

Play up the fact he’s created these weapons that he now won’t hand over to the government. It was touched on in the film, but play up the political angle. If the American public can deal with 24 having countless scenes with the president du jour discussing the day with their confidantes, Iron Man can amp up the political intrigue a little without losing box office dollars.

I hear the next Spider-Man is gonna play up the teen movie aspect. This is a good move if done right. It’ll take the emphasis off the usual origin film formula and should place the focus on an interesting character.

Joss Whedon is directing the Avengers film. If anyone can break superhero films out of the formulaic state they’re constantly flirting with, it’s Joss.

Superhero films are getting better as the more daring ones continue to do well at the box office, but it’s taking time. And every time I see a film like Iron Man 2, I see a great cast, funny lines, nice visuals and a weak ass story.

All I ask is that the next time a comic character with some depth is made into a movie I get a bit more than Punisher: War Zone, Elektra, Wolverine, The Incredible Hulk and Iron Man 2…

… even though, don’t get me wrong, it was a fucking entertaining superhero film and you will probably enjoy it.

In The Truman Show, Jim Carrey’s character discovers that every second of his life has been filmed and broadcast live to millions. While this may sound like the starting point of a bleak dystopian drama, the film takes a more interesting direction by showing the many advantages of Truman’s life over our own existences. Although he’s suffered the stage-managed ‘death’ of his father and the sinister vanishing of a woman he loved, the show’s creator Christof has striven to give Truman the best life possible.

The huge island studio which has been Truman’s home since birth is a near-permanently sunny place, where neighbours greet each other every morning and his wife coos excitedly over lawn mowers and cocoa (rather than interrupt transmission for adverts, the show raises revenue via hilariously unsubtle product placement). Truman’s life is so perfectly controlled - and idyllic - that until the events of the film he’s never had any reason to question the nature of it all.

After a decade heavily saturated by reality television, The Truman Show’s plot seems even more plausible than it did upon first release. Yet Truman’s life is far removed from the self-conscious wackiness of an average Big Brother contestant - what makes his antics such compulsive viewing is that he lives truly and honestly. As the name slyly suggests, he is a True Man.

When a series of production slip-ups leads him to suspect the truth, Truman becomes desperate to leave the island and confused as to why everyone is preventing him from doing so. A story of this type must first create its world, then question and finally overthrow that world - all of which The Truman Show ably does inside one hundred minutes.

In the aforementioned dystopian dramas, of course, the final step of liberation would be replaced by the world reasserting its oppressive power over Truman. That the film doesn’t follow that darker path is to its credit - a well-written comedy can probe meaningful issues just as deeply as tragedy, with the added benefit of making them more digestible.

Although the entire film is thought-provoking and entertaining, it is the final section which especially shines. By then the premise is fully established and we can follow Truman’s escape attempts in tandem with the reactions of those running and watching the show. It’s also in the final section that greater attention is given to the character I find most interesting - Christof, the show’s reclusive creator and a man who’s clearly devoted the best years of his life to nurturing Truman from afar.

There are obvious God analogies here, but there’s also something more - we find that Christof fully believes Truman’s padded cell is a better home than the cruel world we inhabit. As he points out, the measures which have been taken to stop Truman leaving the island wouldn’t be strong enough if he was truly determined - he may not be free, but at least he’s happy.

I never used to watch a lot of television. It used to just be Buffy and Angel. Then in 2003, Buffy ended and Angel began winding down. At this time, hot off the heels of The Shield’s success, FX developed another original series: Nip/Tuck. I didn’t seek Nip/Tuck out. It was a marriage of convenience. Veronica Mars, Battlestar Galactica, House, Weeds, Dexter, The Inside and many others would eventually come along, but it was Nip/Tuck that provided my maiden voyage into a post-Buffy and Angel world.

Needless to say after the pilot I was hooked. For its first two seasons, Nip/Tuck provided a window to a dark world similar to our own, where perfection was all that matters. As the show went on the world that Nip/Tuck inhabited became less similar. Plot holes slowly started to appear, characters would begin acting out of character and the show descended into a level of absurdity that I had never seen before. The only thing that stayed consistently amazing about the show was the production values, which mixed “deco-noir” sets with razor sharp editing and great music.

Nip/Tuck ended this year. Joining a host of other shows this season: 24 and Lost, most noticeably.

While the quality of the show ebbed and flowed throughout the middle of its 100 episode run, the final nine episodes provided a sharp focus and a return to quality more reminiscent of the first four seasons. Old plots were revisited, themes tied up and creator Ryan Murphy’s focus was kept strongly on the two lead characters: Sean McNamara and Christian Troy.

As final seasons go, Nip/Tuck kinda nailed it. It may not have been the show it once was but as each episodes passed a feeling of inevitability permeated the show. These characters, who had steadfastly refused to learn from their various mistakes throughout the series, could not go on as they were. Something had to give – and from the season seven premiere “Dan Daly” onwards, you knew it was going to give soon.

In the pilot, Sean McNamara was introduced as the discontent family man. His wife resented him, his son was a screw up and while his life seemed perfect on the surface he was torn between wanting to leave the hedonistic life of cosmetic surgery behind to help third world countries or be like his suave and adulterous business partner, Christian Troy. Throughout the series, Sean lost his family and dabbled in Christian’s lifestyle, never succeeding with quite the same finesse as his partner. As the seventh season begins, Sean again feels trapped in his life as a plastic surgeon and he’s resenting Christian because of it. When his wife, Julia, returns and announces she’s getting remarried and is moving to London, Sean loses everything. In the finale, “Hiro Yoshimura”, Sean believes himself to be happy in his current life, free of the commitments that were holding him down and becomes seemingly happier spending the rest of his life giving botox and boob jobs to the rich and the vain.

Christian, meanwhile, was a victim of an abusive childhood. His biological father a rapist and his step-father a pedophile, Christian wanted nothing more than to have a family like Sean’s. Time after time during the series, Christian would try and change. But with every attempt to cease the womanizing and settle down with someone, he would fail. In season five, he began a short-lived tryst with Julia, which imploded when he decided that after twenty years of pining she wasn’t what he wanted. He later suffered breast cancer and married Liz, so she’d look after his son Wilbur. Upon being cured they divorced. Then there was Kimber. As damaged as he was, Christian spent much of the sixth season believing him and her to be soul mates despite failed attempts to make it work in the past. This time he thought he could change and it would be different. Needless to say he ended up dumping her and she subsequently threw herself off a bridge. Prompted by Kimber’s suicide and words from Julia, Christian realized in the finale that he was toxic. And with Sean now the closest person to him, he realized no good would come to Sean if their partnership remained. As a result he sent Sean to a third world country, with a recently acquired baby, where he would be able to help sick children, dissolving their partnership.

Both Sean and Christian’s journey throughout the show was mirrored by their final patient, Hiro Yoshimura. Hiro, an elderly porn star, died during after suffering an orgasm induced heart attack while filming his latest porn. The point being: he died doing what he loved. As we’re led to believe Sean and Christian will now both do. The perfect exclamation point to their seven year long midlife crises.

Change. Nip/Tuck was always about change. Each surgery shown in the series was some type of metaphor for change and this theme was most encapsulated in Sean and Christian. By the end of the series, Sean was granted a possibility to actually change – he could use his medical licence to do the work he always wanted and begin raising a new family with his newly adopted baby. Christian meanwhile was content in his self-hatred. Unable to change and not willing to expend the effort to try anymore, the last ever scene of the show has Christian at a bar, picking up a blonde model by using his credentials as a hook. This scene mirrored one of the first scenes of the pilot when he meets Kimber for the first time.

Another character who was unable to change was Matt McNamara, son of Sean, Julia and Christian (long story). After committing a hit and run in season one, Matt went on to do a series of increasingly stupid things: dating transsexual Ava Moore, beating up transsexual Cherry Peck, dating a neo-nazi, joining scientology and marrying Kimber who he later got hooked on meth with, gay porn, dating his new found half sister, trying to become a mime, robbing banks, getting arrested and then killing his cell mate with a bra. You couldn’t make it up. Matt’s series of blunders culminated in the final season when he once again hooked up with Ava, deciding she was the gal for him, and deceiving his dads by running off with her. By the end of the series Matt was as far from perfect or redeemable as any character in television could be.

As a gay man, Ava was different. Her father warned her that to be anything less than normal in such a superficial world would not mean success for Ava. Ergo, after embarking on a relationship with a straight doctor, Dr. Barrett Moore, Ava began a series of gender reassignment surgeries, eventually becoming the “hope diamond of transsexuals.” She even adopted a son, Adrian, in an effort to create the appearances of a normal life. When Moore realized he couldn’t love her even if she was now a woman, Ava fled and went on to antagonize Sean and Christian in season two. She returned in the final two episodes of season seven. This time with a baby, scarred from an illness it had contracted in the third world. Ava wanted normal and asked Sean to fix the baby’s scars. When she learnt they would never fully vanish, Ava abandoned the baby, giving him to Sean. She declared that couldn’t bear to see her child struggle to conform as she had in her life. Matt later met Ava at the airport, offering her what she wanted: a family – him and his daughter, Jenna. She didn’t love him, but it was as close to normal as she was going to get and she took it.

Children. If children are the future, the world of Nip/Tuck is soon heading for an apocalypse. Jenna was shown to be doomed with Matt and Kimber as parents. Similarly, Wilbur, was wetting the bed by the end of the series and seeing a child psychologist because of it. Connor, Sean and Julia’s child, suffered from electrodactyly, with one of his hands normal and the other not. Annie, Sean and Julia’s other child, had already hit puberty, given a blowjob and started eating her hair all before reaching the age of thirteen. None of these children really stood a chance of being able to rise above the sins of their parents.

This brings us to Julia, the personification of wanting what you can’t have. She was with Sean and she wanted Christian. When she was with Christian, she wanted Sean. As the series ends we’re told she’s marrying an unseen character and moving to London. The implication is that she soon won’t be content with that life and will be longing for the melodrama that surrounds Sean and Christian. As she told the pair before leaving for London, “the next time we see each other, it will be as if nothing’s changed.”

Committing suicide in the third episode of the final season, it was the accumulation of both her and Christian’s inability to change that led to her death. Defining herself by the men in her life, Kimber was never able to become her own person, despite a string of occupations that all hindered on her beauty to some degree. Kimber’s character, time and time again, illustrated the tragic consequences of pursuing perfection.

Her counterpart was Liz. The lesbian anaesthesiologist who embraced her flaws and refused to feel bad about them, amidst a cast of characters who were so self-obsessed that they made her look like the second coming at times. Come the final episode, she is pregnant with a child she shouldn’t have by all biological rights and is planning a life as a single parent, continuing to defy social norms – something both Kimber and Ava are unable to do.

For a show about perfection and change, Nip/Tuck became more imperfect the more it tried to change, mirroring many of the character arcs in the show. Meta-commentary or creative misfire? Either way, one thing’s for sure: Nip/Tuck went out on a strong thematic high and it’ll be a long time before another TV show or movie deconstructs the concept of perfection in such a prolific way.

]]> http://www.cold-open.com/2010/05/02/the-imperfection-of-perfection-reflecting-on-niptuck/feed/ http://www.cold-open.com/2010/04/23/wwe-extreme-rules-2010-predictions/ http://www.cold-open.com/2010/04/23/wwe-extreme-rules-2010-predictions/#comments Fri, 23 Apr 2010 20:11:46 +0000 Pasha http://www.cold-open.com/?p=193 Once upon a time ago, the April PPV used to be known as Backlash. An event that promised follow up from the previous month’s Wrestlemania spectacular. In reality, April is a transitional period for the WWE where many of the creative team suffer burn out after putting all their energy into Wrestlemania the previous few months. This means Backlash is usually a series of rematches, with the odd attempt at setting up new storylines for the coming year.

This year Backlash morphs into Extreme Rules, victim of WWE’s newfound themed pay per view fetish. So basically it’s a series of Wrestlemania rematches with the addition of gimmick matches. Sounds ever so thrilling on paper. Except now WWE is aiming its programming towards a PG audience. This means no blood. Not very extreme.

With that in mind, let’s have a look at the card:

Last Man Standing Match for the WWE Title: John Cena (c) vs Batista

Here’s the night’s main event and the first rematch from Wrestlemania. Last month, Batista lost the title. He was the heel in the situation. This month, in all honesty, I expect him to lose again. And I’ll tell you why: Smackdown, the company’s B show, is moving to Syfy in a few months. They’re going to want to give this show a strong start on its new network. Moving John Cena from Raw to Smackdown would do this. And giving him the championship is essential. Why, you ask…

Extreme Rules Match for the World Heavyweight Title: Randy Orton vs Jack Swagger (c)

…because Randy Orton will win this match, taking the championship, and you can’t have two champions on Raw. Over the last month a lot of people have speculated Randy Orton will move to Smackdown in the upcoming “draft.” This is definitely a possibility. Randy, however, has just turned into a face and despite mediocre storylines has been getting huge pops. Moving brand now would kill his momentum. Keeping on the same brand and building him up could make him the next Stone Cold or the Rock. He could be huge. So Orton should win this, which is unfortunate for newly crowned champion Jack Swagger who doesn’t really need the loss at this stage.

CM Punk’s Hair on the Line: CM Punk vs Rey Mysterio

On Raw, Rey cut a strand of Punk’s hair. Mysterio has nothing to lose in this match, so a Punk win wouldn’t be very satisfying. Ergo Mysterio will win and Punk’s going bald. Gee, I sure hope they update his look in Smackdown vs Raw 2011.

Street Fight: Sheamus vs Triple H

For those keeping count, this show now has a last man standing, extreme rules and street fight match. Basically meaning they’re all no DQ matches. Extreme, stuff. As for the match itself… Last month at Wrestlemania, Sheamus lost to Triple H. WWE are trying to build Sheamus up into a legitimate main eventer. A loss here would thus be counterproductive. Therefore Sheamus will win. Plus Triple H has some kind of neck injury and will be looking to take time off. If that can be blamed on Sheamus in the storyline, even better.

Steel Cage Match: Edge vs Jericho

Last month Edge lost. Based on Edge getting the last word on today’s Smackdown, he’s probably gonna lose again today. Then again. Edge is rumored to move to Raw in the draft. If Jericho stays on Smackdown, this could be the end of their feud. In which case, Edge will win. I apologize if you feel cheated by my prediction there.

Extreme Makeover Match for the Women’s Title: Beth Phoenix vs Michelle McCool (c)

I don’t know what the fuck the stipulation for this match means but anything short of them cutting each other up with scalpels is not an extreme makeover. With that in mind, Michelle McCool is screwing the Undertaker, one of the WWE’s big movers and shakers in the locker room, and she is currently tormenting Beth Phoenix for looking like a man in the storyline. Backstage politics and misogyny will see McCool on her way to another victory.

Strap Match: Shad Gaspard vs JTG

These two used to be in a tag team called Cryme Tyme. The Y’s being indicative of their cred with the ghetto urban demo. But they have now split up. Once upon a time, JTG was considered the talent of this tag team. Shad, not so much. However since the split, the focus in the storyline has been on making Shad a credible superstar with a tough new personality (incidentally, he’s gone from stealing stuff with his homies to wearing a suit in the space of one month). The WWE will want to keep Shad’s momentum going (I say that like he had any in the first place). Either way you cut it, he’s winning. And he’s gonna whip JTG with a leather strap to do it. Perfectly heterosexual.

I’m going to preface this review by admitting that I have only read the first The Walking Dead trade paperback. I read it at the end of last year but resisted reading the second trade as all interviews indicated that the show would be quite faithful to the book. Having read the pilot script I am glad of this.

For two seasons Damages did it. A complex show that spanned various timelines, had multiple characters, an intricate plot and a strong thematic through-line. For two seasons these elements were woven together, nary a glaring plot hole in sight.

Season three focused on Patty Hewes’s struggle to recover money from a Ponzi scheme perpetrated by the fractured Tobin family. For much of the season it looked like the third year would stand up there with Damages’s first two seasons. The dynamics of the Tobin family mirrored that of Patty’s makeshift professional family. Ellen Parson’s and Tom Shayes’s family lives were likewise explored as well. The season was looking very focused, something many wish season two had been.

Then the season began drawing to a close. The show’s trademark flash forward scenes vanished. The finale drew nearer and nearer and there was no sense that things were coming to a close. Suddenly a subplot where Ellen thought she was adopted began emerging. For any other show these would be troubling signs. The viewer might start to worry that things wouldn’t make sense come the end of the finale. Damages had induced a similar feeling of dread during the first two seasons. But it had pulled it off then. Surely it would in its third season.

Not so.

The finale, entitled “The Next One’s Gonna Go in Your Throat”, started off shakily. Within the first minute or so, Keith Carradine’s Julian Decker was revealed to be a character from Patty’s past and not the present day architect we had assumed. This was revealed via flashback. The viewer is to infer that Patty had been hallucinating this character the whole season, which is all well and good, however this was an anti-climactic way to make that reveal. There was no great moment of revelation from Patty with her realizing she’d been hallucinating. The catalyst for her suddenly remembering Julian Decker this season was left vague. It was anti-clmactic.

Then there are the plot holes. The many, many plot holes. I can forgive contrivances. Patty’s son steals Ellen’s car that she was in turn borrowing from Tom? Okay, it’s confusing, but I can go with it. Patty’s son uses said car to crash into his mother at full speed at a crossroads? Sure, why not. What does not make sense is Tom not calling emergency services after being stabbed in the gut yet still making his way across town to his home. Don’t buy it.

Earlier in the season one of the flash forwards mentioned Tom and Ellen planning to start their own firm. We then see Ellen visiting Tom’s wife after his death, asking “who else knew about Tom and I?” Neither plot point was addressed in the finale.

Midway through the finale, Patty randomly decided to drop the case based on very little motivation. This was seemingly done to accommodate a flash forward from earlier in the season.

Then we have Tom’s death. He was drowned in a toilet. A regular since the first season was given a fatal swirly. There is an argument to be made for killing him this way. It was shocking, unexpected and horrifying. Ultimately, however, it felt gratuitous and manipulative.

Despite these complaints, The Next One’s Gonna Go in Your Throat” did boast a slew of nice character moments. During his arrest, Ted Danson’s Frobisher was visited by the ghost of Ray Fiske. The story behind the loss of Patty’s child was a powerful one and spoke volumes about her character, even if the execution of the reveal felt rushed and clumsy. Ellen and Patty’s conversation in the closing few minutes was also great.

Likewise, the acting in the episode can’t be faulted.

What I am left with more than anything else from the finale is the sense that this episode played as a cautionary tale. It highlighted the limitations of making it up as you go storytelling. Damages has always been a structurally complicated show. It was nothing short of a miracle that for the first two seasons everything was tied up so well and in many ways the flaws of the third season were inevitable. Especially for a show that didn’t know if it was returning.

When all is said and done I don’t know what I find more depressing: Tom dying in a toilet, the fact this episode has tarnished what was an otherwise great show or the possibility that this could be the last episode and the show went out on such a low note.

Yesterday the UK Government announced intentions to crack down on internet piracy of films, music and television. While this is a threat the government rolls out on a seemingly bi-monthly basis, one must wonder if anything will ever come of it. And if something does I, for one, do not think it will be a good thing.

I am not going to justify the downloading of movies and music. I think those things should be paid for legally. Nor will I justify the downloading of television that has been released on DVD. My intention is instead focused solely on television that has yet to be released on DVD.

As the internet creates an increasingly globalized world, people from all walks of life are able to meet each other and get in contact to discuss common interests. As technology continues to involve this will become more and more common and cultural divides will inevitably erode as a result. What does this have to do with piracy? It’s simple.

The television business model shows seemingly little appreciation for the notion of globalization. Just this past television season, Joss Whedon’s Dollhouse debuted on FOX in America in February. Coming from the creator of Buffy the Vampire Slayer there was much hype and anticipation behind the show and if you’re a fan of cult television that uses the internet the hype and news were unavoidable.

However if you were a British fan, you were royally screwed.

The show didn’t start airing in Britain until at least three months after it aired in the States. By which point, even the most careful of fans who uses the internet would be thoroughly spoiled on all the major plot points.

And what of the aired versions? Sci Fi, the cable station that airs Dollhouse season one in the UK, would change the act breaks, due to OFCOM’s arcane rules about advertising, and cut a couple of minutes out of each episode. As a television purist I’m a big fan of seeing the final product as the creator intended. I like act breaks where they’re supposed to be. I don’t like sloppy network cuts of episodes. So short of waiting even longer and getting even more spoiled until the DVD is released, what is a fan to do but pirate?

With films and music this problem does not arise. Release dates are roughly the same and none are arguably as good for watercooler (read: internet forum) conversation as discussing your favorite television shows. However with television this is very much an ongoing issue.

At this point I will give props to Sky One and Channel Four for airing Desperate Housewives, Lost, Bones and 24 mere days after they are shown in America. But what of the Dollhouses of the world where you have to wait months and months only to be subjected to an edited and diluted version of the show?

If Dollhouse and similar shows were shown within a week of their US airdate… If the act breaks were left in tact… If they were left uncut… If there was a Hulu-esque service on a par to the one offered Stateside… If all these conditions were met, which in this day and age aren’t out of the question, I would condemn people who pirate TV as I do people who pirate other forms of media. But the fact is there is a huge chasm between the wants of fans of US imports and the UK stations’ ideas of what their viewers want and until this chasm is closed I can’t get behind the idea of prosecuting and punishing people who download television.

Teacher. Husband. Father. Cancer patient. On paper, Walter White (the brillaint Bryan Cranston) is an incredibly sympathetic man who you can’t help but feel sorry for. Season One of AMC’s spectacular Breaking Bad worked hard in establishing its protagonist as an ultimately good guy, someone to root for. He gave up on the opportunity to be a rich scientist, instead working as a high school chemistry teacher, not being paid enough to afford his cancer treatment. His son (RJ Mitte) suffers from cerebral palsy, and we are left cheering when Walter turns to violence to stand up for his son. All of his aggressive little acts merit a smile, actually… From taking out his frustration on a smarmy business man’s car, to blowing up an insane drug dealers room, it’s hard not to be on Walt’s side. Even his violent murder of a chained up drug dealer in his basement was justified… Hey, that guy had a shard of broken plate, it was him or Walt. Season Two, making the best move it could have, heads in the opposite direction to Season One. Meet Heisenberg, an inverse of Walter White’s identity, and at the same time perhaps the man he’s been all along.

We ended Season One prematurely, perhaps, due to that ever-soul-destroying writers strike. It closed on Walter and his protégée Jesse Pinkman (the Emmy-nominated, and deservedly so, Aaron Paul) making a deal with the devil, the vicious and unpredictable Tuco (Raymond Cruz). Much like any Faustian arrangement, it quickly falls apart. Tuco, after beating a lackey to death on a whim, has dragged Walter and Jesse into his business, and now they’re a threat to him. This story actually fits very well into S2’s arc, despite the conclusion of it in “Grilled” feeling more like a season finale. Tuco, descending into a paranoid crazy son of a bitch who kidnaps the pair with wild dreams of having them shipped off to Mexico to cook meth for him there, really does lose sight of why he is dealing. His uncle, a wheelchair bound man who can’t or won’t appreciate his grandsons efforts, serves as a bleak reminder of Walter’s own situation. Both men, in the space of one episode, risk a loved one for their own sick need to dominate in the drugs trade. Tuco almost loses his grandfather to poison intended for himself; Walter almost loses his brother-in-law (Dean Norris) to a bullet meant for him. Eventually, Tuco dies much like he deserved to… Gunned down to stop him from a fit of intense rage. You could say the threat is now over. Everyone got away safely. As the pink toy bear in the opening scene of the season tells us: no fucking way.

Following this almost-season-finale, we begin a new journey into the depth of identity. For Hank, it is not only having a chink in his armour revealed, but having the entire helmet pulled off of him. Having faced what isn’t short of a monster, suddenly the man who laughed at a dead body crushed beneath a car is jumping from a bursting bottle of beer. His bravado is utterly annihilated in perhaps one of the most jaw-dropping scenes I have witnessed on television, as he is faced with a mans head on a tortoise and a fellow agent with his leg blown off, a horrific glimpse into the true hell of the drug world. And despite the devil being dead, Walter is still bound for this hell, walking directly into it of his own accord.

Walter’s identity undergoes multiple changes, contrasting with the guy we forgave for dealing back in the first season. Does he cover up the terrible climax of his encounter with Tuco by going back to his family, ready to make up for sins past? Not at all. He figures faking amnesia in an elaborate scheme involving walking around a supermarket naked is the way to go. Who knows, perhaps he’s naked because he’s a newborn again… Heisenberg has officially been born. Lying to his pregnant wife (which he does over and over again throughout the season, even though it is tearing their relationship to pieces) is the best option in his eyes.  Skylar (Anna Gunn) has every right to turn on Walter after his actions this season.  She even goes back to work, showing she is willing to lead an honest life and try to scrape through that way.  She’d never accept the money Walter is making if she knew the source.  Her reaction to her new boss, who she seems tempted to have an affair with, breaking a fairly minor law is telling.  She almost walks out of her job because of it.  Walter’s lies in turn leads to the eventual disintegration of their relationship, concluding with her leaving him in the finale. His own son changes his identity to Flynn, which amusingly Walter objects to completely despite doing the same thing to himself in his dealer lifestyle. His handling of his son is generally awful, from corrupting the innocence of his sons appeals website by replacing the kindness of strangers for money made on the back of fuelling drug addicts. The image of Walter hiding a gun and drug money in his own impending child’s bedroom shows the sick contrast between the two sides of his personality. His overwhelming need to dominate leads to him literally making his son drink himself ill, whilst arguing with Hank over his “territory”, foreshadowing the eventual fate of another “kid” he will encounter later in the season. By the end of the season, we see not a family man, but a man alone, watching the sky literally fall down because of his actions. Alone.

His role as a teacher is also looked at in good detail this season, and ultimately he fails completely as one. Jesse Pinkman, despite no longer being at school, is no doubt Walter’s student. Except this time he isn’t asking for homework, he is asking for a thieving addict to be punished for stealing from him. This leads to the disturbing “Peek-a-Boo”, in which Jesse’s life is put in danger undergoing that very task for Walter. The most important thing to note, perhaps, is Jesse actually looking out for a kid in need, trying to protect him as opposed to exploit him. This isn’t where Walter’s going to lead Jesse over the season, unfortunately. Another lie leads Jesse and Walter into the desert, with nobody there to help them, where Walter rips Jesse apart with words rather than encouraging his better side. The fact remains, however, that on some level Walter does care… This isn’t some one-dimensional asshole who only uses Jesse for drugs. The teacher/student dynamic is still there, but it is one torn between that of Walter caring for Jesse and Heisenberg’s frustration. In a way, Jesse’s friends make up a class. One of them being shot dead by a child, and the other arrested, shows where it’s all going to end up for the students of Heisenberg. With the entrance of Jane (an excellent turn by Krysten Ritter), we finally hit a tipping point. She’s a threat to Heisenberg, and she brings out the worst in Jesse. She’s the real catalyst that leads to the tragedy looming in the distance, inevitable, since the first scene of the season. Ultimately we see Walter White, the father figure, in a scene where he talks to Jane’s father (John de Lancie) in a cruel quirk of fate in which Jane’s fathers love for his daughter ultimately convinces Walter of what must be done. Realizing that she’s going to drag Jesse down into the depths of addiction, and towards death, Walter finally finds the two sides of his identity meeting in one devastating scene as she chokes on her own vomit. Walter, protective of Jesse, needs her gone to save his student, hell, his family, and Heisenberg is well aware that she is blackmailing him. At the same time, this moment is a complete inverse of any other scene in which we witnessed Walter’s darker side… He lets a damaged girl die in front of him, his close friends girlfriend. She doesn’t have broken glass to stab him with, she isn’t threatening him with a gun. In this moment, we see the old Walter fighting beneath the surface, revealed in a tear. But what’s done is done. There’s no way back for him now.

In an interesting but ultimately needed twist, we also begin to move away from Walter’s role as a cancer-ridden man. I mean, a cancer patient doing it for his family? Yeah, we’ll make some exceptions. But now? He has the money, he is getting better physically and yet he doesn’t stop. His very reason for becoming what he has is gone and yet he doesn’t stop. In one scene we see him standing in a queue waiting to buy some paint with the everyday people, and walking out from their ranks to threaten some fledgling dealers to stay out of his territory. He’s becoming a territorial animal in many ways, and this in turn works well when he’s growling at small animals to get out of his way, but sooner or later he’s going to run into something a lot bigger. Be it the far more cautious and savvy Gus (Giancarlo Esposito), or the cartel who cut a man’s head off then blew up an entire group of police, it is going to happen eventually. There was a backlash against the final scene in which we found out those dead bodies looming in Walt’s future were just unknowns thrown from the wreckage of a plane crash Walt unwittingly orchestrated because it was expected that thugs had gone after someone in the White household… I wouldn’t rule out that fate for any of them just yet.

Going into S3, we will be moving into new territory yet again. Season One introduced us to a normal man who turned to crime out of desperation and a series of cruel circumstances. Season Two focused on the consequences of taking the route he chose, transitioning the man we had all grown to root for into a very different man, now deep in the drug trade and having driven everyone he cared for away… His family have left him, Jesse is devastated and in rehab… The movement of identity from Walter White to Heisenberg will no doubt continue, with his own brother-in-law beginning to really go on the search for Heisenberg whilst raising charity for Walter at the same time. Both family member and nemesis, father figure and corrupter, crime lord and fragile school teacher… Walter White is a man of contrasts, and I can only see S3 bringing the two worlds closer and closer together. There can’t really be a happy ending for Walter now… The events are still in motion, the plane crash was just some shock and awe to alert us to it even moreso. If anything I expect S3 to be even darker than what came before, from the man who took a deal with the devil in S1 to a member of the damned deep in the circles of Hell. And I can’t wait.